“You are alleging that the 2 particular person plaintiffs had been denied the precise to vote. However at backside, you are asking this courtroom to invalidate greater than 6.eight million votes, thereby disenfranchising each single voter within the Commonwealth. Might you inform me how this outcome may presumably be justified?”

On Saturday, the choose successfully answered his personal query by dismissing the lawsuit and saying, “this Court docket has been offered with strained authorized arguments with out advantage and speculative accusations…and unsupported by proof.”

The Giuliani courtroom look got here on the identical day two Republican members of the Wayne County Board of Canvassers briefly blocked certification of votes in Michigan’s most populous county, the place Biden outpolled Trump by greater than 332,000 votes. Each board members acquired a supportive name from the President afterward. It was additionally the day Trump fired Chris Krebs, the Homeland Safety Division cybersecurity official whose sin, within the President’s eyes, was to declare there was no signal of systematic fraud on this yr’s election.

The Trump-Giuliani situation of a rigged election, which Joe Biden really received with a convincing electoral faculty victory and a preferred vote margin of greater than six million votes, appeared ripped from Lewis Carroll’s “By the Wanting-Glass,” the sequel to “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.” The Queen tries to steer Alice which you could imagine unattainable issues — and means that it helps should you observe. “Why, typically I’ve believed as many as six unattainable issues earlier than breakfast,” she declares.

The selection now could be “Donald Trump vs. democracy,” wrote John Avlon. For Republicans, “it is a check of whether or not you imagine in our nation greater than a cult of persona. It is a query of whether or not senseless hyper-partisanship will overwhelm any remaining sense of precept. This shouldn’t be a tricky name … Which aspect are you on?”
Within the Washington Publish, Paul Waldman put it starkly. “No president in American historical past has ever earlier than spent the top of his time in workplace attempting to discredit our democracy, degrade the federal authorities and set People towards one another,” Waldman wrote. The Republicans, “are ending the Trump presidency the best way they began it, with a present of complicity and cowardice.”
A number of different attorneys had withdrawn from representing Trump’s aspect within the case earlier than Decide Brann, so Giuliani made the argument. “Rudy did Rudy, ranting usually about stolen elections, fraud, the ‘dishonesty’ of Philadelphia, and ballots illegally solid, in a freewheeling presentation supported by no info and having nearly nothing to do with the amended grievance that had been filed by his colleagues,” wrote Jennifer Rodgers.

“When questioned, nevertheless, about particular allegations, governing authorized requirements, and particular person items of proof, Giuliani was pressured to again down in essential methods, partly as a result of he possessed no related proof supporting his claims, and partly as a result of he appeared unprepared and lacked command of the regulation and governing requirements.”

Legislation professor Joshua Douglas wrote that “the injury to our democratic norms will outlast Trump’s time in workplace. People of all stripes should double down on our dedication to a democracy wherein the losers graciously admit defeat and battle for one more day. Mendacity about election fraud, as Trump and others have achieved, and turning a blind eye when a shedding candidate personally reaches out to an election official, when the candidate doesn’t just like the outcomes, can’t develop into the brand new regular.”

Reality vs. Trump

In Georgia, Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger stated that Sen. Lindsey Graham, a Trump ally who’s chairman of the Judiciary Committee, recommended to him in a telephone name that legally solid ballots may very well be thrown out. Raffensperger had ordered a hand recount of the vote, and on Friday, Georgia licensed the outcomes as initially projected: an upset win for Biden within the traditionally pink state.

Frida Ghitis noticed indicators of an rising break up within the GOP. “On one aspect is the truth-denying, ethically imperiled practitioners of whatever-Trump-says-is-gospel. The opposite, invigorated by the problem of defending democracy, is presumably a lot smaller or on the very least much less noisy. Its members acknowledge actuality, even when it says their occasion misplaced, and are preventing for top ideas, together with democracy. It’s on this smaller section of the occasion the place Republicans could but discover redemption.”

When Jim Kolbe first ran for Congress in southern Arizona as a Republican in 1982, he misplaced by lower than 3,000 votes. The longer term 11-term congressman nonetheless remembers the painful second when he known as his Democratic opponent to concede — the step Trump is refusing to take.

“Failure to concede an election when the end result is for certain and past doubt undermines the very basis of our democracy — the general public confidence that elections determine who will information the nation or the state or the town,” Kolbe noticed. “Pointless disputes over fictional ‘fraud’ solely fuels disinformation, will increase mistrust in our constitutional type of authorities, and weakens belief of their leaders and the very strategy of holding elections.”

Covid-19 Thanksgiving

The Covid-19 information couldn’t be worse: The variety of new instances across the US hit a single-day document this week, and the day by day dying toll is rising.

However the Covid-19 vaccine information couldn’t be higher: There are two vaccines in growth that seem like 95% efficient.

Getting from the terrible now to the hopeful future is a leap — and with Thanksgiving coming this week, there’s an actual threat that extra journey by People will unfold the virus even quicker.

Future-tense hope is difficult by the truth that the long run is a fragile place, cognitively,” wrote Robert Sapolsky, an professional on human habits. “Sacrificing quick pleasure (an enormous gathering at Thanksgiving, for instance), for a much bigger future achieve (much less illness and dying) is hard for people.”
Writers have lamented the unwillingness of some People to make sacrifices within the pandemic, however we should not be all that shocked, wrote historian Nicole Hemmer. Even the “biggest era” wasn’t totally on board with the restrictions enacted throughout World Battle II. “Private sacrifice for group profit is extremely troublesome,” Hemmer identified.

“People sacrificed in the course of the struggle, as they do as we speak, for a variety of causes: altruism, meals shortages, poverty, laws, social strain. The kind of sacrifices People made throughout WWII had been, as typically as not, necessary and resented. They required not simply legal guidelines however intensive propaganda campaigns, extreme social sanctions, and common exhortations that a bit sacrifice on the house entrance would save numerous lives on the frontlines.”

On Monday, David Perry wrote, “We all know extra lockdowns are coming, however this time, we may prioritize youngsters over bars, eating places, understanding, sports activities and socializing in our houses. It is time to maintain faculties and day cares open — and shut nearly every thing else down.”

However on Thursday, the nation’s largest public faculty system, New York Metropolis, closed its faculty buildings and moved to totally on-line studying, on account of a rising common of Covid-19 instances — whereas indoor eating and gymnasiums remained open.

Jill Filipovic wrote that there is loads of blame to go round for America’s insufficient response to the pandemic. “With optimistic check and hospitalization charges rising, and winter and the vacations looming, there may be each motive to imagine that issues will get a lot, a lot worse earlier than they get higher. Sadly, our elected officers have failed us at almost each degree, from the White Home to governors and metropolis mayors — and not simply within the pink states the place Covid-19 denial thrives, however in blue cities and states as properly.”

For extra on Covid-19:

Susan Blumenthal and Emily Stark: The easiest way to make masks work towards Covid-19

What Emily Murphy is not doing

On the day after the 2016 presidential election, Denise Turner Roth, the pinnacle of the US Normal Companies Administration within the final years of President Barack Obama’s second time period, formally “ascertained” that Donald Trump had received.

“My willpower,” she wrote for CNN Opinion, “was primarily based on a number of elements: a evaluate of the outcomes reported by each state, the key information organizations that known as the election for Trump, Trump’s clear margin of victory and the absence of voting irregularities or fraud. As soon as I gave the go-ahead, members of our administration had been in a position to coordinate with President-elect Trump’s workforce to make sure an orderly switch of energy.”

However this yr, almost three weeks after the election received by Joe Biden, GSA administrator Emily Murphy is refusing to determine his victory. That’s stalling the transition in worrisome methods, Turner Roth wrote. “The federal authorities contains some 100 companies and a few 3.5 million staff. None of them can begin cooperating with a brand new administration till the GSA makes its official ascertainment.”

Murphy “has single-handedly created chaos, inefficiency, and ineffectiveness, all whereas steadfastly refusing to answer the American folks, who, in spite of everything, have spoken by the poll field,” wrote Jill Filipovic.

For extra on the election:

Fatima Goss Graves and Kristin Rowe-Finkbeiner: The subsequent massive job for White girls who oppose Trumpism

Maintain Trump accountable?

When the tumultuous transition is lastly over, incoming President-elect Joe Biden’s administration should make a fateful resolution: Ought to it attempt to maintain Donald Trump accountable?

“As soon as the President leaves workplace, he’ll not have the immunity from prosecution he is loved for the final 4 years,” Joe Lockhart famous. “And regardless of by no means prosecuting a former president in our historical past, this time there’s a sturdy case for breaking that norm. Holding President Trump accountable additionally could be the solely technique to maintain our political events accountable.”
Biden, who campaigned on the promise he would heal the nation, will hear pressing cries from Democrats to research Trump, famous Charlie Dent, a former Republican congressman. “Not placing strain on the US Division of Justice to prosecute Trump shall be unpopular with a lot of the Democratic base,” Dent wrote, “however it could be essential to steer the ship of state from turbulent and harmful waters. It will not be simple. The choice shall be extra bitterness and the endless cycle of hostility that outline as we speak’s American political debate.”

Barack Obama’s greatest vendor

The primary quantity of Barack Obama’s presidential memoir bought almost 890,000 copies, together with pre-orders, on its publication day Tuesday, placing it on observe to be the top-selling ebook of the yr. Historian Jeremi Suri known as it a “unhappy and hopeful memoir” that exposed the previous President’s “passionate love for the USA.” The ebook confirmed the bounds to what a president can accomplish “with out cooperation from lawmakers and fuller participation from residents.”

“Obama ran an thrilling marketing campaign on restoring fairness and alternative to People, however he spent most of his troublesome presidency holding off one catastrophe after one other,” Suri wrote. “His recollections of his first time period in workplace are stuffed with repeated frustrations and regrets, born of the crises that repeatedly took him off observe.”

“The reality is that Obama was by no means able to implement a transformative reform agenda like Franklin Roosevelt or Lyndon Johnson. He lacked the legislative tremendous majorities that they had.”

Obama’s presidency was no less than good, wrote John F. Harris in Politico. However he and his supporters had been aiming increased, for really historic accomplishments. “The intelligence and earnestness and self-probing thoughts are apparent on each web page. However by the point the 700 pages of narrative conclude — with the remaining 5 years of his administration nonetheless awaiting a subsequent quantity — it’s clear that these traits do not all the time result in the type of presidency he wished.”

Whether or not the Obama presidency will in the end be seen as nice in its affect on American historical past will rely partly on what comes subsequent. “The choice to his affordable, rational, relativistic mind-set — the choice to the pluralistic world he seeks — is an offended world pushed by individuals who assume like absolutists and haters and zealots,” Harris noticed.

Do not miss


Enter Diana

Josh O'Connor as Prince Charles and Emma Corrin as Princess Diana in season four of Netflix's The Crown
Season four of the Netflix sequence “The Crown” brings the story into the 1980s and spools by the British royal household’s extra unflattering latest years. Prince Charles is “shoehorned by each his mother and father right into a loveless marriage to younger Diana,” Holly Thomas famous.

“Nearly in a single day, he’s reworked from a pensive bachelor whose sister calls him ‘Eeyore’ right into a dispassionate, thoughtless and merciless failure of a partner,” she wrote.

“Within the time-honored trend of British poshos, Queen Elizabeth (Olivia Colman) and co. handle to stay perpetually uncomfortable — bodily, morally and emotionally. Once they’re not trapping their youngsters in tragic unions, they’re trudging up hills within the rain, ignoring the aesthetic disintegration of their palaces, or sacrificing loyal staff to save lots of face. Their ingrained stiffness is matched solely by the rigidity of their hair (Princess Margaret’s is the one mop that ever strikes) — and by that of (Prime Minister Margaret) Thatcher, whose monumental, spherical hairstyle could as properly include its personal bio studying: ‘robust because the Queen, however with greater brains.'”

The royal household’s public relations machine deserves credit score for resurrecting its picture prior to now decade across the youngsters of Diana and Charles — “the extra accessible Princes William and Harry,” Thomas wrote. However the brand new season of “The Crown” is a “strong reminder that even comparatively lately, ‘The Agency’ was in a near-constant state of disaster — and begs the query of how rather more controversy the household’s picture can face up to.”