Smoky eye makeup is one of those classic looks that will never go out of style. It’s heavily customizable, making it adaptable to any occasion, from red carpets to date night to casual day-to-day wear. Despite its popularity, you might not feel confident that a smoky eye is a fitting look for your eye shape due to its reputation of being a pretty intense and often overpowering look. Well, we’re here to tell you that that’s false!

If you’ve found yourself mimicking a smoky eye look that just didn’t look quite right, there’s a good chance that just a minor tweak could get you on the path to an enviable smolder. After all, a smoky eye isn’t a one-size-fits-all kind of deal, and perfecting it comes down to choosing the right colors and blending your product in ways that complement your eyes instead of competing with them. This may sound like a lot to consider, but once you know what you’re looking for, it’s actually really simple. To help, we located 18 stunning smoky eye looks—from soft washes of color to dramatic black moments—and styles with shadow blended every which way on celebrities with all different eye shapes to help you select the best looks for yourself. We promise that there’s a smoky eye look for you here! Keep scrolling to get your life.